And what about saying ameen at the end of Surah al Fateeha ( Surah AL hamdu LILAH ) ?
0 Comments
Regarding Ameen after Surah al-Hamd, there is consensus of the imams of ahl al-Bayt that this is prohibited. This is for a number of reasons: 1st, Allah prohibits speech in the prayer--refer to the tafseer of Qur'an 2:238. 2nd, Allah commands that we be silent during the recitation of the Qur'an--see Qur'an 7:204. 3rd, the Prophet (sawas) said in an authenticated hadith: ((No speech is suitable for the prayer. The prayer is only recitation of the Qur'an, tasbeeh, tahmeed, tahleel)) and in some narrations ((...takbeer...)). 4th, those narrations that say that Ameen was recited are all weak. 5th, there is a hadith where the Prophet (sawas) said: ((When the imam says "...wa ladhdhaaleen" listen silently)).
About the author
Most Recent Questions/Comments submitted
Questions
Thank you for your question! We are presently translating the works of our Imams (as). Most of them are large works which take a long time. The translation as well as editing of the texts is quite an ...
Questions
Do IRS currently plans to translate this book or another works of our Imams (as) ?
Questions
Hi!
Thank you for your question! I apologise for the delay!
Zaydis do not believe that the imams (as) have knowledge of the unseen. This is established in even the earliest sources and authorities. It w...
Questions
Hello.
I wanted to know if Zaydis believe their Imams have had knowledge of the unknown or not? And if yes, what is the source of that knowledge? If it is from God, doesn't it mean Imams were ashabi wa...